As an Amazon affiliate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
In this article, I’ll review the best electric fireplaces with mantles to help you choose the most ideal option for your home.
I Missed My Electric Fireplace
I recently sold my old electric fireplace-the kind that looked like it wandered in from That ’70s Show—and the moment it was gone, my living room felt incomplete. That empty space made it clear I didn’t want another electric fireplace insert or basic space heater; I wanted a full mantel fireplace that felt closer to the real thing.
Interest in the best electric fireplaces with mantles continues to grow as homeowners move toward complete fireplace systems with better safety features and easier daily use. According to Grand View Research, demand in the U.S. electric fireplace market is rising rapidly and is projected to reach $3.11 billion by 2033.
Today’s top options comfortably heat hundreds of square feet, offer adjustable flame colors and layered flame effects, and work naturally in a living room or dining room. Many newer models now feature modern flames or subtle water vapor visuals, delivering ambiance without requiring a wall mount or linear electric fireplace installation.
Key Takeaways from My Research
Here’s how the best electric fireplaces with mantles measured up.
- For larger rooms or statement installs, the Real Flame Alcott 75” and Real Flame Ashley 48” are premium choices, offering wider mantel designs, strong heat output, and multiple flame color options suited for expansive living.
- For mid-range value and everyday use, the BELLEZE 70” Fireplace Mantel and Electactic 43” Mantel Fireplace balance price, performance, and size, with reliable heating coverage and simple remote-based control.
- For a more decorative, furniture-style centerpiece, the BOSHIRO 51” Fireplace with Mantel stands out with classic detailing and adjustable flame effects.
Best Electric Fireplaces with Mantles: Comparison Table
If you’re comparing the best electric fireplaces with mantles, here’s a clean side-by-side breakdown to help you spot the differences that actually matter.
Last update on 12/31/2025 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
#1 – Electactic 43” Electric Fireplace with Mantel (Editor’s Choice / Budget Chic)
Key Specifications
- Size: 43″ freestanding electric fireplace with mantel
- Heating Coverage: Up to 400 sq ft
- Heat Output: 750W / 1500W
- Flame Settings: Adjustable LED flames with variable intensity and ember bed
- Controls: Remote control and onboard control panel
Mini Review
The Electactic 43” consistently shows up among the best electric fireplaces with mantles because it delivers exactly what most people want from modern electric fireplace heaters without overcomplicating things. It’s compact, affordable, and easy to live with-especially if this is your first electric fireplace.
This is the model that I went with as it was the perfect match for my budget and needs.
The flame presentation is simple but effective, with a visible ember bed that avoids the flat, glowing-panel look found on cheaper units. While it doesn’t aim to replicate a high-end electric fireplace log set, it still works well as a beautiful focal point in smaller living rooms, offices, or apartments.
For anyone sorting through different options at Home Depot or Amazon and trying to avoid oversized units or fireplace tv stands, this is a clean, practical entry point-especially during the colder months.
Pros
- Strong value and widely available
- Easy setup using a standard outlet
- Compact size fits smaller rooms
- Super quiet operation for a non gas log fireplace
- Simple controls and ease of use
Cons
- Limited heat coverage
- Narrow top of the unit for décor
- Basic flame effects
Where to Buy
Video Review
🎥 Video Credit: The Jacobs Family
#2 – Real Flame Ashley 48” Electric Fireplace with Mantel (Upgrade Pick)
Key Specifications
- Size: 48″ freestanding electric fireplace with mantel
- Heating Coverage: Up to 1,000 sq ft
- Heat Output: 5,100 BTU
- Flame Settings: Multi-color flames with adjustable brightness and ember bed
- Controls: Remote control and built-in control panel
Mini Review
The Real Flame Ashley 48” is where the best electric fireplaces with mantles start to feel closer to a real fireplace. It has the scale, heat output, and visual depth that many buyers are missing after trying smaller electric units.
If you’ve been debating between electric and alternatives like outdoor electric fireplaces or even traditional setups, this model is the real deal. It highlights the advantage of electric: strong supplemental heat, no venting, and flexible installation options that don’t require structural changes.
Compared to several top models released last year, the Ashley remains competitive thanks to its balanced size, convincing flames, and dependable performance through the winter months.
Pros
- Strong heat output for larger rooms
- More realistic flame presentation
- Traditional mantel design
- Good balance of size and power
- Reliable long-term option
Cons
- Heavier than budget models
- Assembly takes time
- Traditional style isn’t for everyone
Where to Buy
Video Review
🎥 Video Credit: Taotting
#3 – BOSHIRO 51” Fireplace with Mantel (Most Ornate)
Key Specifications
- Size: 51″ freestanding electric fireplace with mantel
- Heating Coverage: Up to 400 sq ft
- Heat Output: 750W / 1400W
- Flame Settings: Multiple flame effects with adjustable intensity and ember bed
- Controls: Remote control and built-in control panel
Mini Review
The BOSHIRO 51” is the most visually dramatic option on this list of best electric fireplaces with mantles. It’s designed for buyers who want their fireplace to be the centerpiece of the room, not just a heat source.
If you like the look of traditional hearths-or have admired outdoor fireplaces purely for ambiance-this delivers that same sense of presence indoors. The carved mantel and proportions give it a more furniture-like feel than many minimalist electric designs.
It’s not chasing hyper-realism like premium brands, but as a decorative electric fireplace, it succeeds by leaning into classic styling and dependable performance.
Pros
- Striking traditional design
- Solid wood construction
- Strong visual depth
- Simple daily operation
- Works well as a focal point
Cons
- Not a minimalist look
- Moderate heat output
- Heavier to assemble
Where to Buy
#4 – Real Flame Alcott 75” Electric Fireplace with Mantel (Best Wide Option)
Key Specifications
- Size: 75″ freestanding electric fireplace with mantel
- Heating Coverage: Up to 1,000 sq ft
- Heat Output: 5,000 BTU
- Flame Settings: Multi-color flames with adjustable brightness and ember bed
- Controls: Remote control and control panel
Mini Review
The Real Flame Alcott 75” is built for scale. If you’ve ever looked at a wall-mounted fireplace and felt it lacked depth or presence, this is the opposite approach-wide, substantial, and designed to dominate a wall.
The large top of the unit provides space for décor, making it a strong alternative to oversized fireplace tv stands. For buyers who want a fireplace that truly fills the room and performs well during extended cold spells, this model delivers.
It’s one of the few best electric fireplaces with mantles that feels intentionally sized rather than stretched.
Pros
- Excellent wall coverage
- Strong supplemental heat
- Large mantel surface
- Multiple flame settings
- Impressive room presence
Cons
- Requires significant space
- Higher price tier
- Longer assembly process
Where to Buy
#5 – BELLEZE 70” Electric Fireplace Mantel TV Stand (Best with Shelves)
Key Specifications
- Size: 70″ electric fireplace mantel TV stand
- Heating Coverage: Up to 400 sq ft
- Heat Output: 1,500W
- Flame Settings: Realistic flame effects with ember bed and sound option
- Controls: Remote control
Mini Review
Rounding out my list of best electric fireplaces with mantles, is the BELLEZE 70”. This attractive wide width hearth with shelves is designed for buyers who value practicality. If you’ve been browsing electric fireplace mantel packages or media consoles, this combines both into one clean solution.
It won’t outperform premium flame systems, but it excels at everyday usability. Setup is straightforward, it runs off a standard outlet, and it’s easy to integrate into an existing room layout without major changes.
For homes where space efficiency matters more than dramatic flames, this is a sensible, well-rounded choice.
Pros
- Built-in storage and shelving
- Space-efficient design
- Simple installation
- Clean, modern look
- Good everyday performance
Cons
- Flames less dramatic
- Lower heat coverage
- Media-focused layout
Where to Buy
Final Thoughts
After living without a fireplace and then diving deep into the research, it’s clear why these models rose to the top. The top picks in this guide all strike the right balance between heat, design, and everyday usability, whether you’re filling a wide wall, upgrading a smaller room, or combining storage with warmth.
The best electric fireplaces with mantles make it easier to add comfort and character without the hassle of gas lines, venting, or complex installs. With the right choice, you get dependable supplemental heat, realistic flame effects, and a centerpiece that feels intentional year after year.
What do you think I should write about next? Are you interested in outdoor gas fireplaces as well? How about portable gas grills for the summer?
📚 Read Next: Best Smart Space Heaters
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Tim Brennan
Tim Brennan, a tech blogger and YouTuber @TecTimmy, writes about smart homes at oneSmartcrib, home theaters at UniversalRemoteReviews, and AI in writing at Writeinteractive. He holds a Journalism degree from Northeastern University and has covered technology for well over three decades. He lives on the ocean in Massachusetts.
Enjoy this? Then you’ll love my YouTube channel. Please subscribe for a fun take on tech with a side of humor. Subscribe