echo auto vs echo dot vs echo input

Echo Auto vs Echo Input vs Echo Dot: What’s the Difference?

In Recommendations, Reviews by Tim Brennan4 Comments

We're an affiliate. oneSmartcrib is reader-supported. If you buy using our links, we may earn a commission. Thanks for the support! 🙏 Learn more

A surprising question I often get asked is: What is the difference between Amazon’s Echo Auto vs Echo Input vs Echo Dot devices?

echo auto vs echo input vs dot

Why is this surprising? I mean, they all sort of look the same.  Two of them are roundish and they are all smallish electronic devices.
And they all let you engage with Amazon Alexa in some fashion.

However…

They are three very different products. They all have Alexa, sure, but that’s where the similarities end. Echo Auto puts Alexa in your car, Echo input lets you enable an existing dumb speaker with Alexa, and Echo Dot is a smart speaker with Alexa built-in.

In the rest of this post, I will take a closer look and examine what each device can and can’t do. 

Echo Auto vs Echo Input vs Echo Dot: Quick Compare

First, let’s start with a quick comparison table that compares these three little devices side-by-side:

Echo Dot
Voice Assistant
Dimensions: 3.9” x 3.9” x 1.7” (99 mm x 99 mm x 43 mm)
Weight: 10.6 oz. (300 grams)
Colors: Charcoal, Heather, Sandstone
Music/Weather/ News:Yes
Built-in speaker: Yes
Lists:Yes
Alarms/Timers: Yes
Shopping:Yes
Games: Yes
Location Aware: No
Hands-Free Calls: Yes
Alexa-Enable Your Speaker: No
Echo Auto
On the Road
Dimensions: 3.3” x 1.9” x 0.5” (85 mm x 47 mm x 13.28 mm)
Weight: 1.6 oz (45 grams) A
Colors: Black
Music/Weather/News:Yes
Built-in speaker: Ye
Lists:Yes
Alarms/Timers: Yes
Shopping: Yes
Games: Yes
Location Aware:Yes
Hands-Free Calls: Yes
Alexa-Enable Your Speaker: No
Echo Input
Dumb Speaker Smarts
Dimensions: 3.1” x 0.5” (80 mm x 13.8 mm)
Weight: 2.75 oz. (78 grams)
Colors: Black and White
Music/Weather /News:Yes*
Built-in speaker: No
Lists:Yes*
Alarms/Timers: Yes*
Shopping: Yes*
Games: Yes*
Location Aware:No
Hands-Free Calls: Yes*
Alexa-Enable Your Speaker :Yes

* When paired with your own existing Bluetooth or wired speaker


What Echo Auto Can and Can’t Do

echo auto vs echo input vs echo dot

The Echo Auto is A Smart speaker for your car. It essentially puts Alexa in your passenger seat. At the time of this writing, Amazon is still shipping the Echo Auto in limited quantities and it remains available on a first-come-first-serve basis. If you want to order one, you will need to reserve one. You can read my full review of the Echo Auto here: Amazon Echo Auto Review: A First Look at Alexa in Your Car.

parristx does a nice job demo-ing the Echo Auto. Thanks for the great review, man.

Can do

  • Turn by turn navigation via Waze and Apple Maps
  • Music, weather, sports
  • Hands-free calling 
  • Location-aware smart device control

Can’t do

  • Enable an existing speaker with Alexa
  • Google Maps

🙈 You can buy Echo Auto over at Amazon.


What Echo Dot Can and Can’t Do

echo auto vs echo input vs echo dot

The Echo Dot is Amazon’s littlest major smart speaker. It is currently available in two generations- 2nd and 3rd gen, but you may be able to find an old gen 1 on eBay. The 3rd generation Echo Dot is a vastly improved upgrade over previous versions of the smart speaker. It features an improved design, better sound, and it is still one of the most affordable ways to bring Alexa into your home. 

CNET puts the Echo Dot through the paces in this informative video review.

You can read my review comparing Echo Dot 3rd and 2nd Gen speakers here: Amazon Echo Dot 3rd Generation vs 2nd Gen: What’s the Difference?.

Can do

  • Music, weather, sports
  • Alarms and timers
  • Smart device control

Can’t do

  • Location-aware smart device control 
  • Turn by turn directions (without some hack)
  • Make a dumb speaker smart 

🙈Check out the latest prices and reviews of Echo Dot on Amazon here.


What Echo Input Can and Can’t Do

echo auto vs echo input vs echo dot

The Echo Input was designed to do one thing and do it well. What’s that? To make your dumb speakers smart. And I use the word dumb adoringly of course. In essence, it brings Alexa to your favorite Bluetooth or wired speaker. Have a bad-ass Bose set up? A sweet home theater surround sound system? You can now talk to Alexa over it thanks to Echo Input.

Tech Spurt does a great job of giving us the scoop on the Echo Input. Dig the accent, my friend.

If you are interested in learning more about other Amazon Alexa devices, don’t miss this post: The Year of Alexa! 7 Awesome Amazon Echo Device Gifts To Give n Get in 2019

Can do 

  • Adds Alexa to your favorite speaker
  • Connect via 3.5 mm cable (included)
  • Connect to compatible Bluetooth speakers 

Can’t do 

  • Anything without an external speaker 
  • Connect to a wifi-only speaker 

🙈You can see the latest price and reviews of the Amazon Echo Input here.


Echo Auto vs Echo Input vs Echo Dot: Price Comparison Chart

The following table is updated nightly with the latest price on Amazon via direct integration with Amazon’s API.  Click the SEE IT button for up-to-the-minute pricing. I will also include some of the other options that I mention in this review.


Echo Auto vs Echo Input: Dumb Question Time?

When doing more than 10 hours of research for this post, I was surprised by the amount of bad information out there. 

This thread on Reddit entitled “Echo Auto vs Echo Input: dumb question time” incorrectly recommends the Echo Input as an alternative to Echo Auto. 

Dumb question time? More like dumb answer time.

As stated above, the sole purpose of Echo input is to convert a regular speaker into an Alexa enabled device. With some serious hacks, you could make that work in your car. However, there are more viable alternatives. The Roav Viva, for example, is good one. Or you could hotspot-enable an Echo Dot and use that instead. But, you won’t get the location-aware benefits of the Echo Auto (i.e., driving directions and local recommendations). Additionally, you won’t be able to play Alexa through your car’s audio system (without some more hacks).

I’m still waiting for my Echo Auto invite and have been for months, but it really is the best way to get Alexa in your car. (I’ve done a ton of research and have seen side-by-side demos, and it’s better than Roav Viva on many levels.) Word on the street is that Amazon has begun actively sending the long-awaited purchase invitations. I hope to have mine soon, and I will update this and write a full review when I do.


Echo Input Vs Echo Dot: Um, Yeah

Same dumb question [sorry].  The thing is that the Echo Input was designed to enable your favorite dumb old speaker [read sweet Bluetooth speaker], NOT to work natively with Alexa.

Without an external speaker, this device is basically a brick.

It’s pretty easy to get once you know that, but I can understand why some people might be confused.

It looks a lot like an Alexa device too, so there is that.

Echo Dot I have blogged about ad nausem elsewhere, so if you want to know more about it check out this post: Echo Dot vs Echo Plus [3rd-Gen vs 2nd-Gen]: Go Big or Go Home?

or this one:

Amazon Echo Dot 3rd Generation vs 2nd Gen: What’s the Difference?

or this one:

Amazon Echo Dot Kids Edition vs Echo Dot 3rd Generation [and 2nd Gen]


Echo Auto vs Echo Dot: A Smarter Question

The Echo Auto is like having an Echo Dot in your car. Plus, you get some additional functionality that just makes sense for the road.

Echo Auto’s location-awareness features mean that Alexa can give you driving directions using your favorite nav tools like Waze and Apple Maps.  Due to the ongoing rift between Amazon and Google, you can’t use Google Maps with Echo Auto though, at least not yet.

Since I’ve been waiting and waiting and waiting [for months] for Amazon to send me my Echo Auto invite, I’ve actually thought about putting an Echo Dot in my car.

How would one do that? Well first you need a power supply, so if your car doesn’t have AC power [mine does] you need to get a converter.  Next, you will, of course, need a Wi-Fi connection.  I have a hotspot on my phone so that would work nicely.

At least in theory.

I haven’t gone there yet because at the end of the day, the location-aware features are really what I want in my car.

So I’ll give Amazon another month to send me my invite.  I might also buy the Roav Viva to do a review. Maybe.


Echo Auto vs Echo Input vs Echo Dot: What Do You Think?

So what do you think of this comparison between Echo Auto vs Input vs Echo Dot?  Were you “surprised” by the differences?

Do you own any of these devices now? Thinking about purchasing any of them?   What do you think about Amazon Alexa?

Do you like monkeys, like me🙈🙉🐵? Monkeys are cool. But do they really like bananas 🍌🍌🍌?

Please leave me a comment below and let me know. I would love to hear from you.


Related Links

You may also enjoy some of our other posts:

Echo Studio vs Echo Plus: Which Alexa Speaker Really Rocks?

Echo Auto vs Roav Viva: Which Alexa-in-Your-Car Device Is Better?

Roborock s5 vs Braava m6 vs 360: Let’s Get Robot Moppin!

Best Smart Light Motion Detectors [One is Pet-Friendly]

Smart Kitchen Technology: 11 Brilliant Accessories and Gadgets Under $200


Echo Auto vs Echo Input vs Echo Dot: Please Like and Share

If you liked this article comparing Echo Auto vs Echo Input vs Echo Dot, would you mind giving us a quick share on social media? You can use the colorful buttons at the top and bottom of this page to share with your favorite social platform.

Thanks so much for your support 🙏!


About the Author

Coredy vs EufyTim Brennan, Technical Writer & Blogger

Tim Brennan [a.k.a. "Tec Timmy"] is a senior technical writer with over 20 years of experience writing for companies and organizations in and around Greater Boston, including GE and MIT. In addition to actively writing for this smart home blog, Tim is also a regular contributor over at UniversalRemoteReviews.com. Tim holds a BA in Journalism from Northeastern University. Brennan is a father to two sons, an active blogger, a Star Wars nut, and loves a good taco🌮. There is a strong chance he is developing a crush on Amazon Alexa. You can learn more about Tim here.

Comments

  1. Alexa-Enable Your Speaker: YES, YES and YES.
    Of course you can use the Echo Dots and Echo Inputs to Alexa-enable any powered speaker. Turn it around and find that wonderful audio output. And if the favorite speaker isn’t powered, you can still Alexa-enable the amplifier. Same for all three models. Seems to me that the main differences are these: the Input is a base model, the Dot ads a speaker while the the Auto ads location awareness. Oh, and the power supplies are different, too.

    1. Author

      Agreed! And really like your summary….I need to update this post especially in light of the new Alexa devices that were announced last week. On the list! Thanks for your comment!
      Tec Timmy

  2. I bought 2 echo input devices 1 I hooked up via aux in my Chevy volt the other through bluetooth in my Ford escape. I use my wifi hotspot for both. Both cars have navigation built in. So for what I use it for the input works great. With a bluetooth connection I get an error message if I try to drop in to other echo devices. But with AUX I can make announcements to my kids at home (our #1 use of alexa) drop in and switch music and pod casts with ease. And for me even easier to stash than the echo auto. And the mic is good as long as the music is not excessively loud

    1. Author

      Hey Kevin,

      I need to retool this post a bit as others have said they are using the Echo Input with good success in their cars. So you basically use drop-in like an intercom system? Cool. Are you able to use any of the navigation features that you would get with Echo Auto? Write me back here if you can.
      Cheers,
      Tec Timmy

Leave a Comment