hue-filament-vs-shelly-vintage-2

Philips Hue vs Shelly Vintage: Which Smart Edison Bulb Is Best?

In Reviews, Smart Lights by Tim Brennan

As an Amazon affiliate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more

In this article, I compare six cool-looking retro LED smart filament bulbs: Philips Hue vs Shelly Vintage.

In this corner, we have Goliath “Philips” Hue.

And in the opposing corner is the underdog upstart “Shelly USA. “

Let’s get ready to rummmmmmmmble.

Live Like A 1950’s Bank Manager

Whether you are into traditional style home décor or just want to add a little rustic look to your existing design, a vintage filament bulb can add a nice touch.

Or as YouTuber Paul Hibbert put it…

”If you want to feel like a 1950s bank manager,” a filament bulb can also get you there.

1st-female-v1-8637693

LOL.

Not long ago there were only a few smart options around for filament style bulbs. Now, however, there are a number of players producing them.

In this post, I am going to compare Philips Hue Edison-style bulbs with those manufactured by one of my new favorite smart home companies, Shelly USA.

What’s so great about Shelly, you ask?  They are obsessed with customer satisfaction, they have super high-quality products, their devices are extensible (think open source), and they are more affordable than the big boys.

But how do their bulbs measure up against Shelly?

First, I’ll start with a comparison of three top Hue bulbs. Then, I’ll compare three smart Shelly bulbs. And finally, I’ll include a downloadable PDF comparison chart that shows all six bulbs side by side.

Hue vs Shelly: here we go.


Photo Gallery: Hue Filament Bulbs

Hue Vintage ST19 White

hue-vintage-st19-white-1-e1601150323233-6256247

Hue Vintage ST19 Amber

hue-vintage-st19-amber-1-e1601150338558-5772490

Hue Filament G25

hue-filament-g25-1-8648792

Philips Hue 551796-2 Smart Filament, 2 Pack, G25, 2 Count
  • VINTAGE STYLE: Capture the popular look of Edison bulbs, featuring a distinct glowing inner coil and transparent globe, with smart filament bulbs. These retro-style LED smart bulbs combine the look and feel of simple vintage design with the power of Philips Hue smart lighting.
  • LIFETIME: 22 years or 25, 000 lifetime hours (based on industry average usage)
  • PREVIOUS HUE CUSTOMERS: This smart light, while Bluetooth compatible, will continue to work with your Hue Hub and can be seamlessly integrated into your current Hue Ecosystem. With the Hue Hub, you can control up to 50 smart lights throughout your home (even outdoor! ). Create timers and routines to automate your entire smart home lighting setup. Control your lights while away from home or add accessories such as motion sensors and smart switches to further enhance your experience.
  • CONTROL LIGHTS WITH YOUR VOICE: Easily connect your Philips Hue Bluetooth vintage smart lights directly with your voice using Alexa or Google Assistant. Works with all Echo smart speakers/displays and Google Nest devices, (Hue Hub required for Echo (1st Gen) and Echo Dot (1st Gen)). For the full Hue experience purchase the Philips Hue Hub (sold separately).
  • EASY TO SETUP: Easy 2-step installation. Just screw in your Hue Bluetooth bulb and download the Hue Bluetooth app to connect directly. Already have a Hue Hub? These lights connect to your Hue ecosystem through the Philips Hue App.

Last update on 25/04/2022 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API


Hue Vintage Comparison: ST19 vs G25

These bulbs are very similar but each has its own unique style.

Note: If you are on a mobile device, you may need to rotate your device to landscape mode to see all three columns.

aHue Vintage ST19 White
Hue Vintage ST19 Amber
Hue White Filament G25
Philips Hue 551770-4 Smart Filament, 4 Pack, A19
Philips Hue White Ambiance Dimmable Smart Filament A19, Warm-White to Cool-White LED Vintage Edison Bulb, Bluetooth & Hub Compatible (Hue Hub Optional), Voice Activated with Alexa, 4-Pack
Philips Hue White Ambiance Dimmable Smart Filament G25, Warm-White to Cool-White LED Vintage Edison Globe Bulb, Bluetooth & Hub Compatible (Hue Hub Optional), Voice Activated with Alexa
Type of Bulb
LED Filament Spiral
ST 19 LED Spiral
LED Filament Straight
Color (Glass Coating)
Clear
Amber
White
Dimmable
Fits Standard Light Socket
Yes, E26
Yes, E26
Yes, E26
Brightness (Lumens)
350 lm
350 lm
550 lm
Color Temperature (Kelvin)
2000
2000
2100
Wattage Equivalent (Rated Power)
5 watts
5 watts
7 watts
Bulb Voltage
120 volts
120 volts
120 volts
Hub Required
No but limited to 10 bulbs per room without Hue Hub
Alexa
Hue Hub required for Echo and Echo Dot 1st Gen.
Google Assistant
Life Time
15,000 hours
15,000 hours
25,000 hours
Mobile App
Yes, Hue Blue Tooth app or Hue app with Hub
Yes, Hue Blue Tooth app or Hue app with Hub
Yes, Hue Blue Tooth app or Hue app with Hub
Local and Remote Control
Embedded webserver
Supports home automation routines
Yes with Hue Hub
Yes with Hue Hub
Yes with Hue Hub
Extensible through programming
aHue Vintage ST19 White
Philips Hue 551770-4 Smart Filament, 4 Pack, A19
Type of Bulb
LED Filament Spiral
Color (Glass Coating)
Clear
Dimmable
Fits Standard Light Socket
Yes, E26
Brightness (Lumens)
350 lm
Color Temperature (Kelvin)
2000
Wattage Equivalent (Rated Power)
5 watts
Bulb Voltage
120 volts
Hub Required
Alexa
Google Assistant
Life Time
15,000 hours
Mobile App
Yes, Hue Blue Tooth app or Hue app with Hub
Local and Remote Control
Embedded webserver
Supports home automation routines
Yes with Hue Hub
Extensible through programming
Hue Vintage ST19 Amber
Philips Hue White Ambiance Dimmable Smart Filament A19, Warm-White to Cool-White LED Vintage Edison Bulb, Bluetooth & Hub Compatible (Hue Hub Optional), Voice Activated with Alexa, 4-Pack
Type of Bulb
ST 19 LED Spiral
Color (Glass Coating)
Amber
Dimmable
Fits Standard Light Socket
Yes, E26
Brightness (Lumens)
350 lm
Color Temperature (Kelvin)
2000
Wattage Equivalent (Rated Power)
5 watts
Bulb Voltage
120 volts
Hub Required
Alexa
Google Assistant
Life Time
15,000 hours
Mobile App
Yes, Hue Blue Tooth app or Hue app with Hub
Local and Remote Control
Embedded webserver
Supports home automation routines
Yes with Hue Hub
Extensible through programming
Hue White Filament G25
Philips Hue White Ambiance Dimmable Smart Filament G25, Warm-White to Cool-White LED Vintage Edison Globe Bulb, Bluetooth & Hub Compatible (Hue Hub Optional), Voice Activated with Alexa
Type of Bulb
LED Filament Straight
Color (Glass Coating)
White
Dimmable
Fits Standard Light Socket
Yes, E26
Brightness (Lumens)
550 lm
Color Temperature (Kelvin)
2100
Wattage Equivalent (Rated Power)
7 watts
Bulb Voltage
120 volts
Hub Required
No but limited to 10 bulbs per room without Hue Hub
Alexa
Hue Hub required for Echo and Echo Dot 1st Gen.
Google Assistant
Life Time
25,000 hours
Mobile App
Yes, Hue Blue Tooth app or Hue app with Hub
Local and Remote Control
Embedded webserver
Supports home automation routines
Yes with Hue Hub
Extensible through programming

Last update on 25/04/2022 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API


Photo Gallery: Shelly Filament Bulbs

Shelly Vintage A19

shelly-vintage-a19-1-4142120

Shelly Vintage ST21

shelly-vintage-st21-5754501

Shelly Vintage G40

shelly_vintage_g125-1000x1000-2-e1601150645992-6143376


Shelly Vintage Comparison: A19 vs ST21 vs G40

I love how the Shelly straight filament A19 and ST21 bulbs have a slightly more modern (but still vintage) look. For the more traditional look, check out the G40 model.

Note: If you are on a mobile device, you may need to rotate your device to landscape mode to see all three columns.

Shelly Vintage A19
Shelly Vintage ST21
Shelly Vintage G40
shelly-vintage-a19-1-e1601153764645-9548479
shelly-vintage-st21-e1601153779544-5692785
shelly_vintage_g125-1000x1000-2-e1601153794725-5029205
Type of Bulb
LED filament Straight
LED filament Straight
LED Filament Spiral
Color (Glass Coating)
Clear/ Warm White
Clear /Warm White
Amber
Dimmable
Fits Standard Light Socket
Yes, E26
Yes, E26
Yes, E26
Brightness (Lumens)
750 lm
750 lm
260 lm
Color Temperature (Kelvin)
2700K
2700K
2700K
Wattage Equivalent (Rated Power)
7 watts
7 watts
4 watts
Bulb Voltage
110 volts
110 volts
110 volts
Hub Required
Alexa
Google Assistant
Life Time
15,000 hours
15,000 hours
15,000 hours
Mobile App
Local and Remote Control
Embedded webserver
Supports home automation routines
Extensible through programming
Shelly Vintage A19
shelly-vintage-a19-1-e1601153764645-9548479
Type of Bulb
LED filament Straight
Color (Glass Coating)
Clear/ Warm White
Dimmable
Fits Standard Light Socket
Yes, E26
Brightness (Lumens)
750 lm
Color Temperature (Kelvin)
2700K
Wattage Equivalent (Rated Power)
7 watts
Bulb Voltage
110 volts
Hub Required
Alexa
Google Assistant
Life Time
15,000 hours
Mobile App
Local and Remote Control
Embedded webserver
Supports home automation routines
Extensible through programming
Shelly Vintage ST21
shelly-vintage-st21-e1601153779544-5692785
Type of Bulb
LED filament Straight
Color (Glass Coating)
Clear /Warm White
Dimmable
Fits Standard Light Socket
Yes, E26
Brightness (Lumens)
750 lm
Color Temperature (Kelvin)
2700K
Wattage Equivalent (Rated Power)
7 watts
Bulb Voltage
110 volts
Hub Required
Alexa
Google Assistant
Life Time
15,000 hours
Mobile App
Local and Remote Control
Embedded webserver
Supports home automation routines
Extensible through programming
Shelly Vintage G40
shelly_vintage_g125-1000x1000-2-e1601153794725-5029205
Type of Bulb
LED Filament Spiral
Color (Glass Coating)
Amber
Dimmable
Fits Standard Light Socket
Yes, E26
Brightness (Lumens)
260 lm
Color Temperature (Kelvin)
2700K
Wattage Equivalent (Rated Power)
4 watts
Bulb Voltage
110 volts
Hub Required
Alexa
Google Assistant
Life Time
15,000 hours
Mobile App
Local and Remote Control
Embedded webserver
Supports home automation routines
Extensible through programming

Last update on 25/04/2022 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Shelly Vintage A19
shelly-vintage-a19-1-e1601153764645-9548479
Shelly Vintage ST21
shelly-vintage-st21-e1601153779544-5692785
Shelly Vintage G40
shelly_vintage_g125-1000x1000-2-e1601153794725-5029205
Type of Bulb LED filament Straight LED filament Straight LED Filament Spiral
Color (Glass Coating) Clear/ Warm White Clear /Warm White Amber
Dimmable Yes Yes Yes
Fits Standard Light Socket Yes, E26 Yes, E26 Yes, E26
Brightness (Lumens) 750 lm 750 lm 260 lm
Color Temperature (Kelvin) 2700K 2700K 2700K
Wattage Equivalent (Rated Power) 7 watts 7 watts 4 watts
Bulb Voltage 110 volts 110 volts 110 volts
Hub Required No No No
Alexa Yes Yes Yes
Google Assistant Yes Yes Yes
Life Time 15,000 hours 15,000 hours 15,000 hours
Mobile App Yes Yes Yes
Local and Remote Control Yes Yes Yes
Embedded webserver Yes Yes Yes
Supports home automation routines Yes Yes Yes
Extensible through programming Yes Yes Yes

Hue vs Shelly: Full Comparison Chart PDF

I couldn’t get this giant Hue vs Shelly comparison table to display nicely on mobile as well as desktop so I created a separate PDF comparison that you can view instead.

You can download the full comparison chart here or click on the thumbnail below.

hue-vs-shelly-pdf-download-1-e1601154753197-9842687

Hue vs Shelly Comparison PDF


Style: Swirls or Sabers

All of these bulbs sport that old school “Thomas Edison style” look and feature distinct glowing inner coils under a transparent dome.

The idea behind these bulbs is that you leave them exposed, either via a hanging ceiling light or on a lamp with no shade.

They look way too cool to cover them up.

I like the style of the Shelly sabers bulb better as the vertical filament coils give the light a retro and modern feel at the same time.

If you want swirls all of the Hue retro bulbs are that way. If its sabers you’re after, check out the Shelly line.


Hue vs Shelly: Brightness

The Shelly bulbs win hands down there.  The A19 and ST21 weigh in a very bright 750 lumens where the more ornate Vintage G50 is just 260 lm. Both Hue ST19 bulbs are 350 lumens and the popular Hue white filament G25 tops out at 550 lumens.

That is almost a whole bulbs difference in brightness from the top two Shelly bulbs.


Hue vs Shelly: Type and Power

All of the bulbs are LED bulbs, and they will all work with your smart home and devices such as Amazon Alexa and Google Assistant.

The benefit of LED bulbs is that they can produce the same amount of light as incandescent bulbs but they use less energy (watts).

This video from Bulbs.com does a nice job explaining the benefits:

Power-wise the bulbs are very similar. Shelly’s two bright bulbs are 7 watts and the G50 is 5 watts. Respectively, Hue’s 350 lm bulbs are 5 watts and the 550 lm bulb uses 7 watts of power.

Since LED bulbs are energy efficient by design, the power differences between Hue vs Shelly are really marginal here.


Are LED Filament Bulbs Energy-Efficient?

Generally, conventional filament bulbs are not as energy efficient as traditional incandescent bulbs, as they convert less than 5% of the energy they use into visible light. However, LED filament bulbs are more efficient: a traditional incandescent filament bulb uses 3.3 lumens per watt which is very inefficient compared to LED bulbs at around 100 lumens per watt.

All of the bulbs featured here take advantage of light-emitting diode technology so they are energy-efficient. The lifespan of these bulbs is remarkable as they can last over a decade or more.

The Super Bright LEDs YouTube channel does a really great job explaining the difference in this video.


Hue vs Shelly Conclusion: Which Edison Bulbs to Buy?

Even though I am a fan (and have a ton) of Hue smart bulbs in my crib, I am going to recommend Shelly here. The bulbs are brighter and less expensive. I also think those saber-style bulbs look cooler.

Unlike Paul Hibbert, I don’t think Philips Hue is the devil, although their products often come at a premium price and many of them require a separate hub or bridge.

Oh, and I like supporting the little guy on the block too when it’s warranted.

You can pick up Shelly bulbs over at the Shelly USA Online Store here.

If Philips Hue is more your thing, you can get the Hue vintage bulbs over at Amazon.com.

Here is the Shelly Vintage ST21 7w bulb in my favorite beach lamp.

shelly-vs-hue-beach-lamp-1-scaled-1392190

I feel like the hippest bank manager around.


Related Posts

If you liked this post comparing Philips Hue vs Shelly Vintage, you might also enjoy some of these articles:

hue-filament-vs-shelly-vintage-2